The bulk update request #2149 has been rejected.
remove implication blue_sky -> sky
remove implication cloudy_sky -> sky
remove implication gradient_sky -> sky
remove implication multicolored_sky -> sky
remove implication night_sky -> sky
remove implication orange_sky -> sky
remove implication red_sky -> sky
remove implication starry_sky -> sky
Reason: As you all know, sky has for over twelve years been reserved by definition for posts where the sky is a focal point or the actual subject. All of these implications were apparently made without consideration for this ages-old wiki. Consequently, there are countless posts incorrectly tagged sky by implication — post #3573568, post #3628524, post #3669793, and post #3673970, to cite a few recent examples — despite the sky being only an incidental part of the backdrop.
Preserving the status quo makes no sense. If these implications are left in place, we must either:
- apply the same usage restrictions to all the tags implicating sky, so that tags like blue sky or cloudy sky can no longer be used on posts not focused around the sky, or
- open up the sky tag to incorporate all posts with any visible portion of the sky, regardless of how small or irrelevant it is to the scene.
EDIT: This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.
EDIT: This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 60 days.
Updated by DanbooruBot