๐ŸŽ‰ Happy 19th Birthday to Danbooru! ๐ŸŽ‰
Danbooru

Tagging a character when they aren't present

Posted under Tags

A general unwritten rule (or what I believe is one, since I haven't been able to find it mentioned anywhere) is to tag characters if they appear as dolls, small keychains, chibi, an icon representing them, anything as long as it's recognizable. For example post #5438900, post #3409251, post #4332618, the entirety of character doll, etc.
(This has also been partly discussed in topic #15982, because an artist kept adding many small characters to his artworks, and tagging them polluted searches.)

However, although the aforementioned rule also applies to cosplays, it is only applied sporadically for when a character's clothes appear.
post #3891684, post #1491381, and post #828442 show recognizable clothes of other characters and yet aren't tagged, while post #4410756, post #4579131, or post #5023566 do.
Another odd example that comes to mind is characters clearly interacting inside the artwork, but being out of frame, such as post #4735661.

It would be nice to have clear guidelines on the approach of tagging characters without the character necessarily appearing.

I see no reason why a character's costume should not be tagged with its chartag. We already do this with cosplay tags for example, which automatically add the original character every time they're used. All of the posts you linked would be something you'd expect to find when searching for the character they belong to.

For examples like you gave, the clothes imply the presence of the characters and mean they're involved in the image, even though they're not directly present, so I still think it's reasonable to tag them.
I can't imagine really anyone who searched for Alice Margatroid wanting post #3891684 excluded from the results.

1