Danbooru

Fire standardization

Posted under Tags

Pokeball99

BUR #16357 has been rejected.

Show

create alias flame_aura -> fiery_aura
create alias flame_trail -> fiery_trail
create alias flaming_arm -> fiery_arm
create alias flaming_arrow -> fiery_arrow
create alias flaming_bird -> fiery_bird
create alias flaming_butterfly -> fiery_butterfly
create alias flaming_chain -> fiery_chain
create alias flaming_crown -> fiery_crown
create alias flaming_ears -> fiery_ears
create alias flaming_eye -> fiery_eye
create alias flaming_eyes -> fiery_eyes
create alias flaming_halo -> fiery_halo
create alias flaming_hand -> fiery_hand
create alias flaming_head -> fiery_head
create alias flaming_hearts -> fiery_hearts
create alias flaming_horns -> fiery_horns
create alias flaming_object -> fiery_object
create alias flaming_skull -> fiery_skull
create alias flaming_spear -> fiery_spear
create alias flaming_sword -> fiery_sword
create alias flaming_weapon -> fiery_weapon

This is an attempt to standardized the state of fire related tags, I'll be making a followup BUR in this thread to for aliasing to flaming_* instead and let it be voted upon which, if any, should be done.

I have not looked into if these are worthwhile tags as the point of this BUR is for standardizing, so if any of these are trully worthless/not relevant to standardization, that can be mentioned so i can remove them from the BURs.

Reply
zetsubousensei AngryZapdos Pokeball99 World Funeral avidbookreader sabisabi KotoM Nameless Contributor blindVigil ion288
Pokeball99

BUR #16358 has been rejected.

create alias fiery_background -> flaming_background
create alias fiery_beard -> flaming_beard
create alias fiery_bow -> flaming_bow
create alias fiery_clothing -> flaming_clothing
create alias fiery_ears -> flaming_ears
create alias fiery_eyebrows -> flaming_eyebrows
create alias fiery_footsteps -> flaming_footsteps
create alias fiery_hair -> flaming_hair
create alias fiery_headphones -> flaming_headphones
create alias fiery_horns -> flaming_horns
create alias fiery_penis -> flaming_penis
create alias fiery_tail -> flaming_tail
create alias fiery_toy -> flaming_toy
create alias fiery_aura -> flaming_aura
create alias fiery_wings -> flaming_wings
create alias flame_aura -> flaming_aura
create alias flame_trail -> flaming_trail

see forum #239267

Reply
ion288 Pokeball99 World Funeral avidbookreader Nameless Contributor AngryZapdos blindVigil Shibi
AngryZapdos

"Flaming" implies flames (yeah I know, water is wet), but in post #2250463, post #1820254 etc. the fire is just embers. As such, I'm much more inclined to go with fiery_x over flaming_x. "Fiery" refers to any kind of fire, meaning flames and embers alike are both included under its umbrella.

I know it's only a small detail, but cases like these where the options are almost identical should be decided on said details. Slightly more accurate is still more accurate, after all.

Reply
AngryZapdos

I dealt with flame_decal manually. It was just a three-post duplicate of flame_print, which in turn shouldn't be aliased. "Flame print" is a common English phrase for fire patterns; a Google search for "fiery print" returns less than 10% of the results.

flame_flyer is a Mario Kart kart. https://www.mariowiki.com/Flame_Flyer

I dealt with flame_saber manually. It's a weapon from Kamen Rider Agito. However, "flame saber" is ambiguous; a number of other fictional weapons bear the same moniker, so I qualified it to flame_saber_(kamen_rider). https://kamenrider.fandom.com/wiki/Flame_Saber

flame_style is one of Kamen Rider Wizard's forms. https://kamenrider.fandom.com/wiki/Haruto_Soma#Flame

I dealt with flame_wheel manually. One post was a ring of fire, the other was an unqualified Pokémon move.

tl;dr, the following tags should be removed from both BURs:
flame_decal
flame_print
flame_flyer
flame_saber
flame_style
flame_wheel

Additionally, flame_tattoo -> fiery_tattoos should be flame_tattoo -> fiery_tattoo instead.

Updated

Reply
blindVigil

I can't say I support much of these suggestions. "Fiery" and "flaming" both describe things that are on fire. A tattoo of a fire is not a "fiery" or "flaming" tattoo. It is a flame tattoo. Some of these things could probably be renamed, or get some utility aliases to make them more visible, but anything that doesn't involve actual burning fire, or something that resembles it, should not be changed to sound like that's what they are. You simply can't standardize every single one of these tags, imo.

Reply
1