Posted under Tags
BUR #50314 has been rejected.
mass update hoshimachi_suisei comet -> object_namesake
hoshimachi_suisei comet yields 7 pages of posts, but hoshimachi_suisei object_namesake yields only 3 posts. As her name is confirmed to mean comet (not Mercury) by being written 彗星 in Chinese, depictions of her with comets should be tagged object_namesake.
sun-dried_tomato said:
BUR #50314 has been rejected.
mass update hoshimachi_suisei comet -> object_namesake
hoshimachi_suisei comet yields 7 pages of posts, but hoshimachi_suisei object_namesake yields only 3 posts. As her name is confirmed to mean comet (not Mercury) by being written 彗星 in Chinese, depictions of her with comets should be tagged object_namesake.
Did you check to make sure there weren't any cases in which the comet's presence is unrelated to Suisei being in the image? For example, being in a group with other VTubers or being in a completely separate image in a collage?
BURs for things like this are generally not a good idea because there might be cases like those. You'd need to check to see if it actually applies to all of the current posts, and even then, there's the possibility someone could upload an image that doesn't fit before the BUR is passed.
Even in solo images, pictures like post #4021076, post #4219144, post #5227994 and post #5641022 are stretching it.
I can agree that some of these pictures should have the object namesake tag on it, but I think it's better to just tag them individually rather than through a BUR.
Also, I do wonder if making a tag like comet (symbol) or similar would be a good idea, because the comet tag on post #5227994 and post #5641022 is kind of a stretch too.
rainyd said:
Even in solo images, pictures like post #4021076, post #4219144, post #5227994 and post #5641022 are stretching it.
In post #4021076 and post #4219144, I can't find any comet. Is her hair ribbon meant to represent one?
If the comet is symbolized, not actual, then comet_(symbol) would be better.
sun-dried_tomato said:
In post #4021076 and post #4219144, I can't find any comet. Is her hair ribbon meant to represent one?
If the comet is symbolized, not actual, then comet_(symbol) would be better.
The first one is in her shadow cutting through her waist. Not sure about the second one to be honest.
The bulk update request #50314 (forum #397172) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.
