Posted under General
Is Nanachi's default look S by virtue of being technically topless? She's an androgynous, mascot-like furry character with no secondary sex characteristics so I've always G'd her but noticed it disputed a few times, for example post #5515491, post #5523809
Having trouble with this one post #5590766. What level of sexuality/intimacy is in this because it feels weird in a fetishistic way and the pose is very suggestive despite it mostly being an innocent situation? I overrated due to the age level of Made In Abyss characters. Maybe male child is more suitable too but I'm not sure.
Daspletosaurus said:
Having trouble with this one post #5590766. What level of sexuality/intimacy is in this because it feels weird in a fetishistic way and the pose is very suggestive despite it mostly being an innocent situation? I overrated due to the age level of Made In Abyss characters. Maybe male child is more suitable too but I'm not sure.
Definitely not just male_child. We do allow S shota now, but I would vote for keeping it on Q.
Should this be rating s instead of g?
post #5604769
TenaciousTurtleDucks said:
Should this be rating s instead of g?
post #5604769
Yes.
Unbreakable said:
S
post #5676966, post #5682534
not sure why these are s, because of zettai ryouiki?
post #5682504, post #5677242
and these are borderlines, I want to make sure at what point do stuff like skirt, thighhighs, sleeveless count as g?
Updated
post #5678363 should be E?
Talulah said:
post #5678363 should be E?
Yes.
magcolo said:
post #5676966, post #5682534
not sure why these are s, because of zettai ryouiki?post #5682504, post #5677242
and these are borderlines, I want to make sure at what point do stuff like skirt, thighhighs, sleeveless count as g?
Yes, zettai ryouiki should usually be S. I started by going through Miku posts but there is a lot of them to check.
I whish I could give you a required skirt length for G but this is art, not science. post #5676966 was just on the S side of the line by my reckoning.
Sleeveless is usually fine for G but armpits can be S.
Unbreakable said:
I'd say rating:q at most.
Is post #5801705 S or Q? I rated it Q, but someone changed it to S.
VR-Man said:
Is post #5801705 S or Q? I rated it Q, but someone changed it to S.
Not shot that's S. It should probably be E.
Unsure about these two.
Unbreakable said:
Unsure about these two.
Both are S.
Could I get a second opinion on rolling_eyes is:sfw? I was trying to judge how many posts have the exasperated eye roll instead of just eyes back, but I noticed a lot of posts feel misrated.
Unsure whether posts like post #5880550 & post #392182 should be G or S. The rating guidelines don't really have anything to say about images that don't actually depict violence but could still be described as mildly scary or threatening.
Nell said:
Unsure whether posts like post #5880550 & post #392182 should be G or S. The rating guidelines don't really have anything to say about images that don't actually depict violence but could still be described as mildly scary or threatening.
Because being scary has no influence on rating. If there's no violence and nothing sexual, then it's G. post #5880550 might be S for her skirt, not sure, but post #392182 is unquestionably G.
