Could this really be counted as guro?

I think Guro is referring to the dismembered stuffed animal O_o

I don't think guro counts for stuffed animals. Especially when whoever put the tag there neglected to tag the stuffed animal itself.

Well, the stuffed animal gets personified in the game, and Maria views his personified form as he gets ripped apart, so it kinda counts.

You'd have to play the game to understand

Tag what you see. No blood, entrails and shit = no guro.