Techincally they all count as magical girls but Saber is sort iffy in that aspect. Though she does transform and does swing around a magical item of great power.
Fragbet85 said: They...can blow stuff up? Effectively. Dunno about Black Rock Shooter though, I've only seen pictures of her.
Oh she can blow stuff up all right. VERY effectively, especially when enraged enough to enter Insane!Black Rock Shooter...
truesword24 said: Black Rock Shooter is not a magical girl and is not a transformation...
If that world isn't magic, I don't know what is. You could count her as a magical girl, just... not in the traditional Mahou Shoujo sense of the word...