Danbooru

imply heart_necklace -> necklace

Posted under Tags

Erytropus

BUR #10901 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication heart_necklace -> necklace
create implication carrot_necklace -> necklace
create implication chain_necklace -> necklace
create implication magatama_necklace -> necklace
create implication key_necklace -> necklace
create implication anchor_necklace -> necklace
create implication skull_necklace -> necklace
create implication shell_necklace -> necklace
create implication gold_necklace -> necklace
create implication crescent_necklace -> necklace
create implication ring_necklace -> necklace
create implication feather_necklace -> necklace

If we're gonna do heart_necklace we might as well do all the other ones.

Reply
Lyren Unbreakable Zumzigzoo user 893647 The Bob Daspletosaurus Hyozen ion288 Nacha Immersed sadodere sabisabi ppp laivu stato
Unbreakable

BUR #10907 has been rejected.

create alias heart_pendant -> heart_necklace
create alias anchor_pendant -> anchor_necklace

I think we should do this too (heart necklace wiki even describes it just like a pendant), if someone is wearing a pendant tag pendant, if someone wants to only see necklaces do a -pendant search together with the other tag.

I only choose to do the ones listed in the above BUR and also has a corresponding *_pendant tag, if someone wants an alias for the rest before they are created it can be added.

Reply
ion288
madokamisama

Unbreakable said:

BUR #10907 has been rejected.

create alias heart_pendant -> heart_necklace
create alias anchor_pendant -> anchor_necklace

I think we should do this too (heart necklace wiki even describes it just like a pendant), if someone is wearing a pendant tag pendant, if someone wants to only see necklaces do a -pendant search together with the other tag.

There are lot of posts tagged with heart_pendant that don't have a necklace. The same is true for the single image tagged anchor_pendant. A pendant and a necklace are different things, both according to the Danbooru Wiki and Wikipedia. A pendant is a loose-hanging piece of jewelry. It may hang from a necklace or something else, for example a choker.
Your proposed change would tag a lot of pictures with chokers or collars with heart pendants incorrectly as having a heart necklace.

Reply
nonamethanks

Unfortunately the pendant tags are a real mess, because necklaces technically are pendants too if they have anything attached. It's just basic english.

I mentioned this in forum #170696 2 years ago. heart choker for example has a lot of heart pendants, when it's not about heart o-rings. A solution would be to have pendant tags be implied by the subtypes (such as heart necklaces, heart pendant chokers etc), but there's so many weird corner cases that I can't see it working out well (like the aforementioned heart choker where the tag is for mainly two different kinds of heart objects: a heart pendant and a hole in the choker in the shape of a heart), and of course just using necklace + heart_pendant is just shooting ourselves in the foot.

Reply
evazion

Erytropus said:

BUR #10901 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication heart_necklace -> necklace
create implication carrot_necklace -> necklace
create implication chain_necklace -> necklace
create implication magatama_necklace -> necklace
create implication key_necklace -> necklace
create implication anchor_necklace -> necklace
create implication skull_necklace -> necklace
create implication shell_necklace -> necklace
create implication gold_necklace -> necklace
create implication crescent_necklace -> necklace
create implication ring_necklace -> necklace
create implication feather_necklace -> necklace

If we're gonna do heart_necklace we might as well do all the other ones.

Flower necklace is a blocker. Currently it's used both for leis and for necklaces with a flower ornament. Using it for leis is a problem because necklace implies jewelry and I don't think a lei is jewelry.

Reply
1