Nuking Colored Petticoats

BUR #42593 has been rejected.

nuke white_petticoat
nuke red_petticoat
nuke black_petticoat
nuke pink_petticoat
nuke yellow_petticoat
nuke blue_petticoat
nuke purple_petticoat
nuke aqua_petticoat

Noticed the sudden existence of colored petticoat tags, which I really don't think we need.

I also noticed a lace-trimmed petticoat tag, but I'm not sure what to do with that one. I just know colors are too much.

You might want to add a line for white_petticoat to mass update add the regular petticoat tag to the posts before the nuke. There are about 8 pages of posts missing it. I went through the other tags already and did it manually since there weren't that many. Also, should these be deprecated so they don't get recreated?

TenaciousTurtleDucks said:

You might want to add a line for white_petticoat to mass update add the regular petticoat tag to the posts before the nuke. There are about 8 pages of posts missing it.

Already did it manually.

TenaciousTurtleDucks said:

Also, should these be deprecated so they don't get recreated?

I normally add a deprecation line, but I didn't know what to write for the wikis beyond a bland "Do not use this tag", so I was hoping just a normal nuke would do the trick. Though given the size of white petticoat, I'm not exactly confident in that...

Given that petticoats are (almost) always white, do we want a tag specifically for colored petticoats?

Every tag made besides white petticoat is really small. I'm not sure of the utility of a colored petticoat tag, but as it stands it can be very hard to search for the concept if you did want to search for non-white petticoats, so I wouldn't mind seeing such a tag.

BUR #43169 has been rejected.

nuke white_petticoat
deprecate white_petticoat
create alias red_petticoat -> colored_petticoat
create alias black_petticoat -> colored_petticoat
create alias pink_petticoat -> colored_petticoat
create alias yellow_petticoat -> colored_petticoat
create alias blue_petticoat -> colored_petticoat
create alias purple_petticoat -> colored_petticoat
create alias aqua_petticoat -> colored_petticoat

Here's an alternate BUR with a "colored petticoat" alias for all sans white petticoat (which should be nuked).

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #42593 (forum #361584) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #43169 (forum #364163) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

It's a bit late now, but when I've come across Gothic Lolita and JFashion people online, petticoat color seems like a fairly common thing to group images by. That is a point in favor of keeping the colored tags, as people who are in that scene might want to search by that.

For the record, all these BURs need is one admin's approval, even post rejection.

Anyway, that only really adds a point in favor of the colored petticoat tag existing. It doesn't really change the fact a petticoat is such a small and often hard to notice detail that I don't see the point in having any more specific tags beyond that.

Knowledge_Seeker said:

Anyway, that only really adds a point in favor of the colored petticoat tag existing. It doesn't really change the fact a petticoat is such a small and often hard to notice detail that I don't see the point in having any more specific tags beyond that.

For me, I agree. I do not need to search petticoats (or actually any clothes) specifically by their color.
I'm just noting that I have seen some people online (GL/JFashion people) who actually would find this a useful search. I've seen a few times people requesting pictures specifically of yellow petticoats, red petticoats, patterned peticoats, so on.
As for it being small or noticable, the images in petticoat seem to take up about as much space in the image as a given image in red_socks (for example) might. There are tags with less screen space like blue_eyes that we want too.