Danbooru

Posts with jack-o'-lantern & pumpkin ornaments

Posted under Tags

I have a feeling that it does not imply pumpkin *because* of those ornament implications. If you have a jack-o'-lantern_hair_ornament, it currently implies jack-o'-lantern, adding a pumpkin implication would start tagging pictures with pumpkin without any real, physical pumpkins around.

And yes, I agree that they are good to have separated, hence I think implication is better than aliasing. However, other solution is to garden all pumpkin_earrings & pumpkin_hair_ornament posts, it's just that people are going to do the same behavior I mentioned in the future as well, which does not remove the problem.

One thing to note is that in the pumpkin_hair_ornament wiki it does state "consider adding the jack-o'-lantern_hair_ornament tag." - but there is no mention about jack-o'-lantern_earrings in the pumpkin_earrings wiki.

BUR #10897 has been rejected.

create implication jack-o'-lantern_earrings -> pumpkin_earrings
create implication jack-o'-lantern_hair_ornament -> pumpkin_hair_ornament

Anyway going to make this request now and let people decide.

So the options are either removing jack-o'-lantern_earrings & jack-o'-lantern_hair_ornament tags from pumpkin_earrings & pumpkin_hair_ornament posts through gardening (so posts have only one each), or to make these implications & add jack-o'-lantern_* to the missing pumpkin_* posts (thus, you can search for pumpkin_hair_ornament -jack-o'-lantern_hair_ornament & pumpkin_earrings -jack-o'-lantern_earrings if you want less flashy ornaments like LQ mentioned.

nonamethanks said:

I created it.

As for the implication: most posts under pumpkin earrings are jack-o'-lantern earrings. I don't really see a point in having such an implication tbh. I count about 20 actual pumpkin earrings under pumpkin earrings, if this went through then jack-o'-lantern_earrings would make up 95% of pumpkin earrings.

So in case the BUR is rejected, should the tags be completely separated from each other through gardening? If so, I think there should be a mention about those on each pumpkin_* wiki, something along the line of "use x instead". Currently the sentence "consider adding the jack-o'-lantern hair ornament tag." doesn't really tell if both should be added or just one.

Lyren said:

So in case the BUR is rejected, should the tags be completely separated from each other through gardening? If so, I think there should be a mention about those on each pumpkin_* wiki, something along the line of "use x instead". Currently the sentence "consider adding the jack-o'-lantern hair ornament tag." doesn't really tell if both should be added or just one.

Of course, wiki updates are done manually so whenever you encounter feel free to add it yourself. In this case maybe wait a bit to see if anyone has other opinions.

Lyren said:

So in case the BUR is rejected, should the tags be completely separated from each other through gardening? If so, I think there should be a mention about those on each pumpkin_* wiki, something along the line of "use x instead". Currently the sentence "consider adding the jack-o'-lantern hair ornament tag." doesn't really tell if both should be added or just one.

Alright, I'll start separating these two tags from each other (removing pumpkin_* from jack-o'_* posts) as well as add jack-o'_* to the missing posts.

1