Danbooru

Ratings check thread

Posted under General

Blank User

Maiden_in_Orange said:

Me neither honestly. If I were uploading this, I would've rated it G with little hesitation.

Me too. I did change it before you commented on it, but it was changed back since then. This seems to be a recurring pattern for this user. More examples of posts that were rated G on upload but changed to S include:

post #6296471
post #6643081
post #6708668
post #6715434
post #6724858
post #6727054

And that's just from glancing through the first few pages of this user's rating changes. This seems like a pattern of overcorrecting ratings for bare shoulders and/or collarbone, which are not emphasized in these images. Considering the user's position, I think this should be brought into the open as soon as possible.

@Unbreakable, can you explain to us why you have been rerating the above posts and post #6713807 from G to S? Being cautious is fine and all, but this seems like overkill.

Maiden_in_Orange said:

post #6745532

Are her breasts too emphasized for G on this one? I've been trying to be better about rating posts like that S, but this pool has otherwise been G so far, and this one feels about as G otherwise...

I'm on the fence on this one; the breasts don't really seem all that emphasized, but the shirt does look a little bit tight around them.

Reply
Knowledge Seeker

Blank_User said:

I'm on the fence on this one; the breasts don't really seem all that emphasized, but the shirt does look a little bit tight around them.

BobTheBuilder_v1 said:

I would rate it up because of the low v-neck, despite not having cleavage it's a bit different than a standard t-shirt neckline.

Ah, it was the shirt that was giving me pause here. Yeah, that shirt is pretty low-cut and appears fairly form fitting to me overall. It's certainly a pretty soft S though. I think what I'm going to do is keep it at S, but you won't see me put up a fight if it were to be changed to G. Thanks, this one needed a second look to make sure that was right.

Reply
smowtenshi

hdk5 said:

Not gonna argue about loli, but those look S and not Q to me

https://danbooru.donmai.us/post_versions?search[post_id]=4843693&type=current#post-version-51245708

seems S to me

https://danbooru.donmai.us/post_versions?search[post_id]=6740513&type=current#post-version-51245701

leaning more towards Q than S

https://danbooru.donmai.us/post_versions?search[post_id]=6698153&type=current#post-version-51245689

definitely Q

https://danbooru.donmai.us/post_versions?search[post_id]=6715748&type=current#post-version-51245683

this one looks kind of innocent, so i'd say S

Also, posts uploaded from baraag are mostly (if not all) loli.

Reply
hdk5

zetsubousensei said:

These 2 have mild cameltoe which is an auto Q, Gwar in particular.

Just in case, subtle cameltoes and not-too-revealing bikinis are both listed under S, not Q though:

Rating:Sensitive

...
Skimpy or revealing clothes, including swimsuits, lingerie, underwear, cleavage cutouts, playboy bunnysuits, skin tight or impossible clothes, etc.
...
Subtle cameltoes or covered nipples not blatant enough for rating:questionable.
...

Rating:Questionable

...
Near-nudity, such as highly revealing clothes or swimsuits, clothing that barely hides nudity, and clothing that is partially removed or torn.
Nipples or genitals clearly visible though clothing, including covered nipples, pronounced cameltoes, wedgies, bulges, and erections under clothes.
...

Reply
smowtenshi

hdk5 said:

Just in case, subtle cameltoes and not-too-revealing bikinis are both listed under S, not Q though:

well, yes, but there's also statement saying that

[...] if an image is loli or shota, it lowers the requirements for what is considered "sensitive" significantly.

Reply
Unbreakable

Blank_User said:

@Unbreakable, can you explain to us why you have been rerating the above posts and post #6713807 from G to S? Being cautious is fine and all, but this seems like overkill.

It's a (young) girl in light, kinda revealing clothing, to me it's insane that someone would even consider rating it as G, the neckline is about where her breasts should start.

Reply
wispydreamer

Unbreakable said:

It's a (young) girl in light, kinda revealing clothing, to me it's insane that someone would even consider rating it as G, the neckline is about where her breasts should start.

There's a large bow obscuring the neckline and there's absolutely nothing seen but collarbone and shoulders, both due to the bow and her pose.

Reply
1 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 59